Healthcare Professionals

Maintaining medical opposition

Healthcare professionals have long been opposed to legalising practices which their experiences tell them are uncontrollable, unethical and unnecessary. None of the major medical bodies have contradicted this view and a change in the law is formally opposed by the Association for Palliative Medicine, the British Geriatric Society and the World Medical Association. High profile consultations in 2018 and 2019 saw opposition remain the most favoured stance among members of the Royal Colleges of General Practitioners and Physicians, with the former reaffirming its opposition, and the latter clarifying ‘that it does not support a change in the law to permit assisted dying at the present time,’ noting that ‘professional and clinical issues pose significant challenges to the success of any future legislation’ and that ‘the majority of doctors would be unwilling to participate actively in assisted dying if the law were changed to permit it.’

The Royal Colleges of Nursing, of Surgeons of England, of Psychiatrists* and of Anaesthetists, are neutral; the Royal Colleges of Physicians and Surgeons of Glasgow*, and of Physicians of Edinburgh*, have no specific position (*confirmed 2021 in response to the McArthur consultation).

The British Medical Association (BMA) surveyed members on “physician-assisted dying” (which it used to refer to both euthanasia and assisted suicide) in 2020. Support for a change in the law was highest among those least involved in the treatment of patients (medical students and retirees) while opposition rose in line with proximity to dying patients (palliative medicine doctors, geriatricians, GPs and respiratory specialists.) The BMA adopted a motion of neutrality on “physician-assisted dying” by just four votes in 2021.

Opposition must be maintained; if you are a doctor, nurse or other healthcare worker, please sign up to Our Duty of Care, a grassroots campaign supported by Care Not Killing.

Past Articles

Thousands of doctors & nurses issue stark warning

Thousands of doctors, nurses and other healthcare professionals say: or the sake of us all, do not rush into hasty legislation but instead fund excellent palliative care

Palliative medicine holds firm on assisted suicide

The Association for Palliative Medicine of Great Britain and Ireland leads members of the specialty in urging MPs not to support Kim Leadbeater MP’s assisted suicide bill

Times ‘fails to accurately reflect’ Congress vote

Our Chief Executive writes in The Times, in the wake of a troubling Anaesthetists Association Congress in Edinburgh.

CNK-ODOC suicide prevention submission 2022

We considered, in particular, the arguments and evidence of the debate on assisted suicide in responding to the Department of Health consultation.

1,700 medics urge rejection of assisted suicide

A press release from Our Duty of Care issued ahead of the Assisted Dying Bill’s second reading in the House of Lords.

CNK CEO on BMA neutrality, and the need for more research

BMA opts for Neutrality on Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia as Leading ‘Choice’ Advocate admits we need more research on Painful Deaths